Sunday, October 26, 2008

Kalau Singapore serang Malaysia?

Okay,kita hari ni bercakap perkataan "kalau" kat sini.Dalam istilah analitik-psikologi,nama dia "counterfactual history".Perkataan utama dalam teori ni ialah "what if",atau apa sekiranya.

Kita semua tahu,masing-masing ada ideologi negara yang tersendiri.Cuba kita lihat jiran kita yang terdekat,Singapura,dan bandingkan dengan Malaysia.

Dari sudut geografi:

Singapura:

Keluasan:707 km persegi.
Penduduk:4,839,400
Parti pemerintah:PAP(People Action Party)
Ideologi:Social democracy.

Malaysia:

Keluasan:329,847 km persegi.
Penduduk:27,730,300
Parti pemerintah:Barisan Nasional.
Ideologi:Ketuanan Melayu,Capitalism.

Kalau kita tengok dari sudut ni,for sure Malaysia boleh menang kalau sekiranya Singapore menyerang Malaysia.Malaysia mempunyai advantage dari sudut populasi,dari sudut muka bumi.Tapi,mari kita tengok dari sudut teknologi militer antara kedua-dua negara ni.

Malaysia:

Ketumbukan tentera:85,000 tentera darat,50,000 simpanan,
Rifle:M4 Carbine(USA),replaced Steyr AUG from Austria in 2009.
Udara:

Helicopter:Eurocopter EC725(aku tau ni ada isu ni,tapi ada org cuba compare dengan Brazil,kita x boleh nak compare dengan harga Eurocopter kat Brazil,pasal Brazil ada kilang Eurocopter kat Helibras.)

1st Division

2 Squadron Fokker F-28 Fellowship, Falcon 90, Global Express, Boeing BBJ Subang AFB
3 Squadron S-61A4A Nuri Butterworth AFB
6 Squadron BAE Hawk 108/Hawk 208 Kuantan AFB
10 Squadron S-61A4A Nuri Kuala Lumpur AFB
11 Squadron Su-30MKM Flanker Gong Kedak AFB (Sukhoi)
12 Squadron Northrop F-5E, F-5F, RF-5E Butterworth AFB
15 Squadron BAE Hawk 108/Hawk 209, Aermacchi MB-339AM Butterworth AFB
16 Squadron Beech 200T Subang AFB
18 Squadron Boeing F/A-18D Hornet Butterworth AFB
19 Squadron MiG 29N/UB Kuantan AFB
20 Squadron Lockheed C-130H Hercules, C-130T Subang AFB
21 Squadron CN-235-200M Subang AFB

2nd Division
5 Squadron S-61A4A Nuri Labuan AFB
7 Squadron S-61A4A Nuri Kuching AFB
14 Squadron Lockheed C-130H Hercules Labuan AFB

Training Division
1 FTC PC-7, PC-7 Mk II, Alor Setar AFB
2 FTC Alouette III Alor Setar AFB


Navy:

[edit] Surface Vessels
Frigates

2 Lekiu class frigates
FFG 29 KD Jebat
FFG 30 KD Lekiu
Corvettes

2 Kasturi class corvettes
25 KD Kasturi
26 KD Lekir
4 Laksamana class corvettes
134 KD Laksamana Hang Nadim
135 KD Laksamana Tun Abdul Jamil
136 KD Laksamana Muhammad Amin
137 KD Laksamana Tan Pusmah
Offshore Patrol Vessels

4 Kedah class offshore patrol vessels
171 KD Kedah
172 KD Pahang
173 KD Perak
174 KD Terengganu
4 Handalan class patrol boats (Swedish Spica-M class)
3511 KD Handalan
3512 KD Perkasa
3513 KD Pendekar
3514 KD Gempita

Fast Attack Craft

4 Perdana class missile boats (French La Combattante II 4AL class)
3501 KD Perdana
3502 KD Serang
3503 KD Ganas
3504 KD Ganyang
6 Jerong class patrol boats (German Lürssen TNC 45 class)
3505 KD Jerong
3506 KD Todak
3507 KD Paus
3508 KD Yu
3509 KD Baung
3510 KD Pari

Mine Counter-Measure Vessels

5 Mahamiru class minesweepers (Italian Lerici class)
11 KD Mahamiru
12 KD Jerai
13 KD Ledang
14 KD Kinabalu

Submarines
2 Perdana Menteri class submarines (French/Spanish Scorpène class)
KD Tunku Abdul Rahman
KD Tun Razak

Auxiliary Vessels

Landing Craft

1 Newport class tank landing ship
1505 KD Sri Inderapura (ex LST 1192 USS Spartanburg County)

Combat Support Ships

2 Sri Indera Sakti class support ships
1503 KD Sri Indera Sakti
1504 KD Mahawangsa

Hydrographic Survey Ships

255 KD Mutiara
151 KD Perantau

Training Ships

76 KD Hang Tuah (training frigate)
KLD Tunas Samudera
MV Fajar Samudra (training yacht)
MV STS Puteri Mahsuri (training yacht)

Tugboats

4 KTD Penyu
6 KTD Sotong
8 KTD Kepah

Air Assets

6 Eurocopter AS 550 Fennec helicopters
6 AgustaWestland SuperLynx 300 helicopters
The SuperLynx 300 is configured for Anti Surface Warfare (ASuW), Anti Submarine Warfare (ASW) and Over The Horizontal Targeting (OTHT) roles. It is equipped with the MBDA Sea Skua antiship missile.

Army:

4 infantry divisions, formed from 10 infantry brigades, 1 parachute brigade and 1 mechanised brigade. The 3rd Division ("Sehitam, Semerah") is converting to become the army's first combined arms formation.

26 Light Infantry Battalions
3 Airborne Infantry Battalions
3 Mechanized Infantry Battalions
5 Armoured Regiments (1 Tank Regiment)
16 Artillery Regiments (4 Low Level Air Defence)
3 Special Forces Regiments
50,000 Active Reserve In approximatelty 60 Infantry (Askar Wataniah) Battalions.

Standard Issue Infantry Weapons

Browning HP handgun
Steyr AUGA1 assault rifle (to be replace by M4A1 Carbine)
M16A1 (as well to be replace in active service)
FN MAG general purpose machine gun
Like most armed forces in the world, the Malaysian Army is in possession of numerous other weapons, mostly to be used by special forces units such as the Grup Gerak Khas or by soldiers with a special assignment such as snipers.

Armour

48 Bumar-Łabędy PT-91M Pendekar Main Battle Tanks.[11]
211 FNSS ACV 300 Adnan Infantry Fighting Vehicles. Additional 30 unit will be deliver expected on 2010 which be announce during DSA 2008.
111 MIFV K200 (Modernized K-200 KIFVs) Armoured Personal Carriers.
26 FV101 Scorpion Light Tanks.
184 Sibmas 90 Armoured Fire Support Vehicles.
460 Rheinmetall Condor Armoured Personal Carriers.
25 Alvis Stormer Light Armoured Vehicles.
80 Haegglunds Bandvagn 206 Light Armoured Vehicles.
04 Avibras AV-VBL Artillery Command Vehicles.
V-150 APC/Armoured Fire Support Vehicles (retired).

Transport

1511 3 Ton 4x4 GS Cargo HICOM Handalan trucks.
168 2 Ton 4x4 Pinzgauer Gun Tractors.
164 2 Ton 6x6 Pinzgauer Mortar Transporters with 144 ammunition trailers.
85 3 Ton 4x4 URO VAMTAC (Vehículo de Alta Movilidad Táctico) High Mobility Tactical Vehicle.
13 6 Ton 4x4 Light Recovery Isuzu FTS33H.
29 5 Ton 4x4 Isuzu FSS32G Communication Shelters.
19 2 Ton 4x4 IVECO M4010 Field Ambulances.
04 2 Ton 4x4 IVECO M4012 Satellite Communication Vehicles.
33 Gomba Stonefield Field Ambulances.
4x4 Land Rover Defender .
4x4 G-wagon (Local Assembly).
Mercedez Benz 911 3 ton (retired)
TATA 1613 3 ton truck.
Bedford RL 3 ton (retired)
Volvo C303 (retired).

Artillery:

18 Avibras (Astros II MLRS) Keris 300 mm Multiple Rocket Launchers.
28 Denel G5 howitzer Mk 3 155 mm Howitzers.
15 VSEL FH-70 155 mm Howitzers.
200 OTO Melara Mod 56 105 mm Pack Howitzers.
29 GDF-005 Oerlikon 35 mm twin cannon.
36 Bofors 40 mm gun 40 mm L/70.
150 M40 recoilless rifle.
8 FNSS ACV-S 300 120mm mobile amour mortar carrier.

Air Defence Missiles:

15 MBDA Rapier missile "Jernas"
700 Shorts Starburst surface-to-air missile (Most mounted on LML launchers)
500 Anza Mk II
200 9K38 (SA-18) "Igla" Man-portable air-defence systems.

Anti-Tank weaponry:

450 Baktar-Shikan
9К115-2 Metis-M
MBDA ERYX
Saab Bofors Dynamics AT4
C-90 CR (M3) disposable rocket launcher.
Carl Gustav M2
M40 recoilless rifle
RPG-7

Radars:

Ericsson GIRAFFE Radar Air Defence.
Oerlikon Skyguard radar
Ericsson ARTHUR Artillery Hunting Radar Artillery finding radar.
Aselsan Askarad GSR

Army Air Wing:

9 SA316B Aérospatiale Alouette III
11 Agusta-Westland A109H


Sekarang kita usha Singapore punya aset.

Manpower:35,000(National Service 350,000)
Rifle:SAR-21(Singapore)<-bikin sendiri tu.

Army:

Type Quantity
Main Battle Tanks ~156
Leopard 2A4 (120mm Rheinmetall L44 main gun) 96 (66 active plus 30 spares) [4]
Centurion Mk 3/Mk 7 (105mm L7 main gun) ~60 [5]
Light Tanks ~372
AMX-13SM1 ~350
AMX-10PAC90 22 (in reserves)
Mechanized infantry Combat Vehicles / IFVs ~1122
AMX-10P 22 (in reserves)
Bionix II (30mm Bushmaster II chain gun/New armour) ~200
Bionix 25 (25mm M242 Bushmaster chain gun) ~300
Bionix 40/50 (40mm AGL + 0.5 inch HMG) ~300
Terrex AV-81 300 (o/o)
Armoured Personnel Carriers/Reconnaissance Vehicles ~1250
M113A2 ULTRA 40/50 (40mm AGL + 0.5 inch HMG) ~700
M113A2 ULTRA OWS (25mm M242 Bushmaster chain gun) ~300
Cadillac Gage V-200 ~150 in storage, 100 in use by RSAF
Multiple Rocket Launchers 18
High Mobility Artillery Rocket System (HIMARS) 18 (o/o)
XM31 HE GMLRS Pod 32
Mortars ~62
81 mm ~?
Soltam M-65 120 mm towed mortar 50 (in reserves)[6]
Soltam M-66 160 mm towed mortar 12 (in storage)[6]
Howitzers ~330
25 pounder Mk II 12 (Ceremonial gun)
Soltam M-68 155 mm Towed Howitzer ~? (in storage)[6]
Soltam M-71 155 mm Towed Howitzer 38 (in storage)[6]
M-114A1 155 mm Towed Howitzer 16 (in storage)[6]
FH-88 155 mm/39-Cal Towed Howitzer 54 (in reserves)
FH-2000 155 mm/52-Cal Towed Howitzer 54
GIAT LG1 105 mm Towed Howitzer 60 (Phasing out end 2008)
SSPH Primus 155 mm/39-Cal Self-Propelled Howitzer (SSPH-1) 54
SLWH Pegasus 155 mm Heli-portable Lightweight Howitzer 54
Armoured Engineers ~?
FV180 Combat Engineer Tractor ~?
M60 Armoured Vehicle Launched Bridge (AVLB) ~?
M728 Combat Engineer Vehicle (CEV) -165mm Demolition Gun ~?
Aardvark JSFU Mine clearance vehicle ~?
Field Engineers ~?
Vehicle Launched Bridge (VLB) ~?
Foldable Longspan Bridge (FLB) ~?
Projected Line Charge (PLC) ~?
Bionix AVLB ~?
Bridging Engineers ~?
M3G Bridge ~?
All-Terrain Tracked Vehicles ~?
Bronco ATTC (GPMG armed/120mm Super-Rapid Mortar) ~?
Bandvagn 206 (GPMG armed) ~?
Anti-Tank Rockets/Missiles ~4000
SPIKE-LR MANPACK 300
Matador ~3000
Guards Vehicles 400
Spike LSV with Twin SPIKE ATGM 200
Spider LSV 200
Direct Fire Weapons ~400,000
SAR 21 >150,000
M16S1 local variant of M16A1 produced under license >200,000
CAR-15 Carbine version of the M-16 (Converting to SAR-21) >5,000
M203 grenade launcher >20,000
Ultimax 100 >20,000
FN MAG 7.62 mm General Purpose Machine Gun >10,000
CIS 12.7 mm HMG >3,000
Sig-Sauer P226 9 mm Pistol ~?
H&K MP-5N 9 mm SMG >2,000
FN P90 5.7 mm SMG ~500
FN Five-seven 5.7 mm Pistol ~500
PGM Mini-Hecate 8.6 mm Long-Range Sniper Rifle ~100
H&K PSG-1 7.62 mm Semi-Automatic Sniper Rifle ~?
Accuracy International L96A1 7.62 mm Sniper Rifle ~?
Accuracy International L115A1 8.6 mm Long-Range Sniper Rifle ~?
Steyr SSG 69 7.62 mm Sniper Rifle ~?
Brügger & Thomet APR308 7.62 mm Sniper Rifle ~?

Air Force:

RSAF Assets Type Country of Origin Role Quantity Program
Fixed Wing Combat Aircraft 123
Boeing F-15SG Strike Eagle United States Air superiority/Strike 24 (o/o) ?
Lockheed Martin F-16C
Lockheed Martin F-16D
Northrop F-5S Tiger II United States Interceptor 28 ?
Northrop F-5T Tiger II United States Interceptor/Trainer 9 ?
Helicopters 78
Boeing CH-47SD Chinook United States Heavy Transport 18 Peace Prairie
Eurocopter AS-332M Super Puma France Medium transport/Search And Rescue 22 ?
Eurocopter AS-532UL Cougar France Medium Transport 12 ?
Boeing AH-64D Apache Longbow United States Attack 20 Peace Vanguard
Sikorsky S-70B Seahawk United States ASW/ASuW 6 (o/o) ?
Transport Aircraft 14
Lockheed C-130 Hercules United States Heavy Transport 10 ?
Fokker 50UTL Netherlands Medium Transport/VIP 4 ?
Support Aircraft 17
Boeing KC-135R Stratotanker United States Aerial Refuelling/Transport 4 ?
Grumman E-2C Hawkeye United States AEW & C 4 ?
Fokker F50ME2 Netherlands Maritime Patrol 5 ?
Gulfstream G550 with the EL/M-2075 Phalcon AESA AEW radar[28]. United States / Israel AEW & C 4 (o/o) ?
Trainer Aircraft 42
Pilatus PC-21 Switzerland Trainer 19 ?
ST Aerospace A-4SU/TA-4SU Super Skyhawk Singapore Advanced/Lead-in Jet Trainer[29] 18 ?
Eurocopter EC-120 Colibri France / Singapore / China Trainer 5 ?
UAV ~40
IAI Searcher Mk 2 Israel Reconnaissance 40 ?
Elbit Hermes 450 UAV Israel Reconnaissance ? ?
Stored Aircraft 69
ST Aerospace A-4SU Super Skyhawk Singapore Fighter-bomber 30 ?
ST Aerospace TA-4SU Super Skyhawk Singapore Trainer 10 ?
Bell UH-1H United States Light Transport 19 ?
Eurocopter AS-550A2 Fennec France Trainer 3 ?
Eurocopter AS-550C2 Fennec France Scout 7 ?
Air Defense Artillery/Surface-to-Air Missiles/Radar
MIM-23B I-Hawk United States SAM ? ?
Mistral France SAM - MANPADS ? ?
Rapier Mk II United Kingdom SAM ? ?
9K38 Igla Russia SAM - MANPADS ? ?
M113A2 Ultra Mechanised Igla Singapore Mobile SAM (SHORAD) ? ?
RBS 70 Sweden SAM - MANPADS ? ?
Cadillac Gage V-200 RBS 70 Singapore Mobile SAM (SHORAD) ? ?
Oerlikon 35 mm twin cannon Switzerland AA Gun ? ?
Ericsson GIRAFFE Radar Sweden Mobile Radar ? ?


Navy:

Submarines:RSS Challenger—commissioned 1997
RSS Conqueror—commissioned 1999
RSS Centurion—commissioned 1999
RSS Chieftain—commissioned 2001

Frigates:
RSS Formidable (68)—commissioned 2007
RSS Intrepid (69)—commissioned 2008
RSS Steadfast (70)—commissioned 2008
RSS Tenacious (71)—commissioned 2008
Stalwart (72)—launched 2005
Supreme (73)—launched 2006

Converttes:
RSS Victory (88)—commissioned 1990
RSS Valour (89)—commissioned 1990
RSS Vigilance (90)—commissioned 1990
RSS Valiant (91)—commissioned 1991
RSS Vigour (92)—commissioned 1991
RSS Vengeance (93)—commissioned 1991

Patrol vessel:
RSS Fearless (94)—commissioned 1996
RSS Brave (95)—commissioned 1996
RSS Courageous* (96)—commissioned 1996
RSS Gallant (97)—commissioned 1997
RSS Daring (98)—commissioned 1997
RSS Dauntless (99)—commissioned 1997
RSS Resilience (82)—commissioned 1998
RSS Unity (83)—commissioned 1998
RSS Sovereignty (84)—commissioned 1998
RSS Justice (85)—commissioned 1998
RSS Freedom (86)—commissioned 1998
RSS Independence (87)—commissioned 1998

Amphibious transport:
RSS Endurance (207)—commissioned 2000
RSS Resolution (208)—commissioned 2000
RSS Persistence (209)—commissioned 2001
RSS Endeavour (210)—commissioned 2001

Mine countervessels:
RSS Bedok (M105)—commissioned 1995
RSS Kallang (M106)—commissioned 1995
RSS Katong (M107)—commissioned 1995
RSS Punggol (M108)—commissioned 1995

USV(Unmanned Surveilance Vehicle)
Protector USV

Missile gunboats:
RSS Sea Wolf (P76)—commissioned 1975
RSS Sea Lion (P77)—commissioned 1975
RSS Sea Dragon (P78)—commissioned 1975
RSS Sea Tiger (P79)—commissioned 1976
RSS Sea Hawk (P80)—commissioned 1976
RSS Sea Scorpion (P81)—commissioned 1976

hmm..Kalau populasi 4.8 juta orang dengan keluasan 700 km persegi dengan equipment macam ni,banding dengan Malaysia,macam mana ni?

13 comments:

Mata Rakyat said...

Aku harap ianya tidak berlaku amboi sampai ke situ angan-angan kau. Moga ianya takkan jadi kenyataan. Kita tak de gaduh sesama jiran, cukupka konfrantasi dulu jangan diulangi permusuhan diplomatik ni. We want peace(my name)

E the Prototype Robot said...

it's obvious that singapore can win technologically.but if we think psychically,Singaporean won't go that far.

Malaysian terrains are mostly jungle,and although they had trained at tropical areas like Pulau Ubin,they won't win if there's a battle in Pahang,for example.

They don't even reach Rompin.

I think,logically,if there's a war between Msia and Spore,urban areas will be key part of the battle.But Msia can start by switching off electricity towards Singapore.Easy.

misz eyeliner said...

kamu fikirkan tentang hal ini? cool~ tak ramai rakyat malaysia mahu buang masa fikir tentang hal ni. ada yg ingat singapore 'tak akan buat', worst, ada yg anggap malaysia sudah cukup selamat.

Anonymous said...

Untuk pengetahuan semua memang ada rancangan Singapura akan menyerang Malaysia tapi masanya akan tiba. Kenalilah siapa yang bertanggungjawap melatih para tentera Singapura???? Tak lain tak bukan ialah Israel yang menyerang Palestine tanpa belas kasihan……Singapura adalah proksi Yahudi Zionis ….Mereka menyimpan makanan dalam stor simpanan dalam tanah yang dapat bertahan hingga setahun……..untuk apa???? Jalan raya mereka bila bila masa saja akan menjadi tempat mendaratnya pesawat mereka yang canggih………banyak lagi cerita yang agak mencemaskan….????? arba03@yahoo.com

Anonymous said...

Quality will overcome quantity. Just look at Israel and the Arab nations surrounding.But let's not forget, the most powerful weapon is a Mu'min's Doa.So be aware of campaigns to eradicate the Iman amongst Muslims.

Makan dan cuba. said...

nampak gaya Malaysia lah akan menang.Tapi,dari segi teknologi Singapura lebih bersedia.Belanjawan pertahanan memang tinggi dari kita.Pemimpin mereka pastinya menggunakan istilah Melayu:siapkan payung sebelum hujan.Tetapi kita disini mungkin gunakan istilah:dengar guruh diawan,air setempayan jangan dibuang.Rugilah mcm tu,air pun mahal.dan banyak lagi istilah2 yang seadanya.Pendek cerita,gunakan segala kelengkapan dan kudrat yang ada.Bertarunglah atas nama mempertahankan negara.Dan nasib2 dapat syahid.

Makan dan cuba. said...

Kita mungkin menggunakan pelbagai taktik juga teknik untuk menyerang.Sedangkan mereka dengan teknologi dihujung jari sekejap sahaja dah kena sasaran.Tapi ingat,sasaran pun kadang tak mengena.Amerika walau canggih sampai hari ni tak dapat cari Osama Ladin.Alasan standard,dah mati.Tup2 timbul baru2 ni buat kecaman.Yakinlah pada kekuasaan Allah Ta'ala dan jangan lupa solat.

Anonymous said...

aku rasa Malaysia boleh menang. Walaupun senjata Singapura lebih canggih dari kita.. tapi kita ramai dan negeri luas. Cuma kita jangan benarkan serangan itu Singapura gunakan dalam kawasan kita seperti Johor...pertahanan Johor mesti kuat// supaya Singapura dapat dilumpuhkan

Anonymous said...

SINGAPURA TIDAK AKAN BISA MENANG PERANG SMA MALAYSIA...SBB KITA MALAYSIA ADA KELEBIHAN AIR....JGN LUPA ITU....JIKA MALAYSIA MEMUTUSKAN HUBUNGAN ANTARA NEGARA...HABIS SINGAPURA ITU KEKERINGAN BEKALAN AIR BERSIH....LAGIPUN KALAU MAU PERANG...CUKUP HANYA KERAHAN 10 SUKHOI DAN MLRS ASTROS II....HANCUR SEMUA...KITA JUGA HANCUR..TP CUMA SIKIT BERBANDING SINGAPURA PASTI HUNDRED PERCEN HABIS MUSNAH DGN BEDILAN BOMB DR SUKHOI DAN MLRS....

Anonymous said...

Cina m'sia n cina s'pore bkrje sme utk mnjatuhkan hak org melayu ke tngn cina.cuba fikir secare mluas dngn skop ini.mrke bleh siap sdia prngkp atau battalion mrke sndiri d dlm ngre m'sia sndiri.tmbhn pule,org yg brtnggungjwb utk mnjge ngre boleh di bli dngn wang ringgit shje.ade lg klemahan malaysia n rakyatnye.tp fkirkan btul2.mnusia akn brtmbah stiap mse.mne prginye mrke dngn ngre skcil itu.m'sia.kpde siape tnh RIZAP MELAYU TRGADAI,cina.d mne trsmpn nye snjte komunis dulu.di HUTAN RIZAP MELAYU.tp x pe.ph lawan malaysia,komando malaysia semuenye hbt dn sngt hebat d mata dunia.cth yg mudah.black hawk down. Tp anak generasi muda malaysia.haha jom relax,enjoy,lets party avry nite,enjoy with girls.buat ank bnyk2.Hurm,,generasi mude,,to young to understand "idiot""huhh ohh ALLAH please help my cuntry malaysia people to have Ur bless n Ur hidayah.Amiin

Chee Kien Tiong said...

Stop all this nonsense talking, I got friends and relatives both live in Singapore and Malaysia. Better concentrate on how to develop our own economy.

fahrul radzy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
فوترا سریویجایا said...

ingt mlrs astros tu saja2 beli ke..54 unit bateri tu. standby la bunker siap2..